Guest Post: Creating Bonds Around Self-Love Instead of Negative Self Talk

by Marzipan on April 29, 2011 · 22 comments

Y’all this guest post has been whipped up for you by the ultra inspiring Emilie Littlehales, of the blog I Came to Run and the Embrace: Me Project. Please welcome her right on into your hearts – she’s adorable.

This past weekend I sat in on a talk on women in running, during which one of the three speakers addressed the issue of body image.  She began her talk by quickly polling the audience, which was made up almost entirely of women: “How many of you feel good about your bodies?”  There was a long hesitation, and then a few hands (including my own) rose tentatively into the air.  I looked around somewhat nervously—there were about fifty women in the room, and maybe three or four of us had our hands raised.  I wasn’t sure what to think; when it comes to body image, I’ve been through hell and back again, so I could certainly relate to those women who chose not to raise their hands.  But my empathy was mixed with a few other emotions: guilt, embarrassment, anger, and a sense of isolation.

From an early age, we learn to dislike our bodies.  There are a variety of factors that play a role in this, but we have to be careful not to underestimate the degree to which our interactions with other girls and women influence us in this regard.  Sooner or later, negative body image becomes a common feeling over which we learn to bond, and a sisterhood that centers on sharing our thoughts on how much we dislike parts of physical selves develops.  It’s a disturbing phenomenon when you take a step back to look at it: you can’t walk into a room one day and declare how good you feel about your thighs, doing so might result in you being the victim of silent, seething resentment.  But say that you feel fat or disgusting, and you will find that the entire room knows exactly how you feel.

Surprise!

image by N1NJ4

To be fair, it’s highly unlikely that we’d judge others by the same standards to which we hold ourselves—a friend who is our exact same size or weight is probably gorgeous in our eyes, maybe even the subject of some jealousy because of how much more attractive we think she is—but the fact that this dynamic exists at all is troubling.  Without our intending for it to, having a negative body image has become something we expect of each other, something that makes us relatable, and much more comfortable with each other than we would be otherwise.  That’s why I felt the way I did when I raised my hand on Saturday; all of a sudden I felt like an outsider, and, even worse, a traitor.

May 25

image by bee wolf ray

Commiserating with another woman about how we feel about our bodies is the kind of thing that we do every day, often without even thinking.  It’s become polite, or expected—it’s just what you do.  We can complain about our thighs, our dress size, our weight, or our diets to women we barely even know, but by virtue of the fact that we’re female, we know we’ll share the same feelings.  It’s become such a commonplace that it can be unsettling to meet a woman who doesn’t feel the same way (how often have you or someone you know joked about “hating” another woman because she seems confident and comfortable with herself?).  The problem is that we don’t often take a moment to think about how damaging this practice is.  In accepting poor body image as a means through which we can bond and forge relationships, we’re acknowledging that it’s not important for us to make an effort to feel any better.  It may be the status quo for us to feel badly about ourselves, but that doesn’t mean it’s right, and it doesn’t mean we should seek out relationships and experiences that enable us to perpetuate our feeling that way.

So I would like to propose a challenge: set aside a period of time, whether it’s a day, a week, a month, or more, and for its duration, make a point to disengage from these bonding experiences.  When you get sucked into a conversation that involves women putting themselves down, remain silent, or even walk away.  If you feel comfortable doing so, you can even say that you don’t want to participate.  If you’re feeling especially brave, explain why.  See if you can create a different bond, one that is more positive, and that will ultimately be more powerful.

Emilie Littlehales writes the blog I Came to Run, where she tends to go on and on about the things she loves most: running, yoga, and working on breaking down the narrow definitions of beauty that our society seems to be so fond of.  She’s also the founder of the Embrace:Me project.  She lives in New York City with the love of her life, and is starting to come to terms with the fact that everyone who told her things will start to sort themselves out once she hits her thirties may be right (she’ll know for sure in less than six months).

  • http://vivacioushealthandwellness.blogspot.com Hannah

    This is so true-I’m in college, and group negative body talk happens all the time. It got so bad that our Res Life had girls coming to them upset because other girls were talking about their bodies/what they ate. As a health rep, I organized a house workshop with a wellness coordinator about positive body image, and we worked on ways to exude positivity/guidance for friends who say disparaging things about their bodies. It’s definitely not easy, but helpful in the long run. Part of the cynical side of me thinks that in the food/exercise blog world, despite bloggers’ clean diets and intense exercise routines, perhaps few of them/us would raise our hands at a conference like that….
    Hannah recently posted..Therapy Homework- Fear- Stomachs- and FriendsMy Profile

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      I have that cynical side, too. The food/exercise blog world is a strange place, and even though I want to make it clear that I don’t blame anyone in particular for this, getting wrapped up in the food/exercise blogs definitely didn’t help me when it came to my own body image issues, and especially not when it came to my eating disorder. I got very taken in by the fact that you only see one side of things, and never stopped to think that the “blog effect” snippet of perfection may not represent the whole picture.

      Good for you for organizing that workshop on positive body image and for being so active in helping to combat the negative talk that was going on. I wish more people would be that proactive! Hopefully it’s something that will start to catch on more and more.
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • http://recoveringinspirings.blogspot.com Kat

    I love this.

    I think if more people start to form relationships or start conversations NOT based around self-loathing, change would be more apt to happen on a larger scale. That’s also why I like fat talk free walk.
    Kat recently posted..A Letter to the EditorMy Profile

  • http://handprintsoul.wordpress.com McKella

    Wonderful.
    Sometimes I feel like my acceptance of my own body alienates me from other women, which is a problem because I’m not especially social in the first place.
    The hardest thing is that my mom still wants to change her body even though she’s had four jumbo-size babies and she looks amazing. We used to go on diets and exercise together. We still love to go for walks and to Zumba together, but I feel like we’re on totally different planes with our attitudes toward food and our bodies.
    McKella recently posted..The falacy of “I can’t”My Profile

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      My mom is very similar to what you’re describing. She exercises, eats well, and takes great care of herself. She’s in her late fifties and she’s in amazing shape. But every time we’re together and almost every time we talk, she brings up calories, what she shouldn’t have eaten, how fat she is, etc. I think it can be especially hard to fight back against fat talk when it comes from our mothers or sisters or other close family members, and especially sad to have to do it at all.
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • http://www.jillwillrun.com Jill Will Run

    Bravo Emilie…. you’ve written this is such a perfect way. It truly explains one of the biggest problems that we women have with our interpersonal relationships with other women. (Love you, you continue to inspire me day-in, day-out!)

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      Thanks, Jill! You are a huge inspiration to me, too! Lots of love :)
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • http://daynya.wordpress.com daynya

    Love this! I completely agree, I always feel like the outsider if I don’t say I hate my body. I don’t hate my body. How counterproductive is that?? Does that accomplish anything?? It’s not like you can trade it in for a new one. Sigh. But I’m more than happy to explain to people WHY I don’t participate in this crap, and why I don’t want to hear them talk about what I should or should not be doing with or putting into my very own body. Thank you for spreading this message!!

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      It’s *awesome* that you aren’t afraid to speak up and tell people why you love your body, and why you don’t want to participate in fat talk! Thank *you* for spreading the message, too!
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • Pingback: Lovely Links: 4/29/11

  • http://chickensoupforthedorkysoul.blogspot.com/ Vanessa

    I never thought about this in quite so much depth. This is an awesome post, and I totally agree. We should start trying to flip our personal scripts on how we treat our bodies in daily interactions.
    Vanessa recently posted..Life After College- LauraMy Profile

  • Amanda

    Really appreciate this post. Thank you for sharing it. I’m definitely going to try and redefine my relationships so they’re not based upon complaining of any kind (but especially body criticism). My mother and MIL are infamous for the “complain about a physical trait and then wait for a the other person to disagree and offer a compliment” style of communication and that’s another tedious back-and-forth I don’t want to participate in any longer.

    I had a relative from the Czech Republic who appeared to have the healthiest self-image I’ve ever witnessed in my entire life. I’m not sure if growing up in Eastern Europe before the Velvet Revolution contributed or if she had remarkably affirming parents or just an innate sense of self-worth but she enjoyed eating good food, drinking good wine, and dressing to make the most of her curves rather than hide them. The thought that she wasn’t completely awesome would never occur to her. At the time she irritated the living daylights out of me (since I was dealing with an ED) but now she’s an inspiration.

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      I can understand the frustration you felt toward your relative–it’s so hard to be struggling with an ED and see other people who are doing so well. But it’s great that you are now in a position where you can see her as an inspiration, and I’m happy to hear that you have someone like that in your life. I hope that you also think of yourself as your own inspiration–I know ED recovery has been one of the hardest things I’ve ever been through, but it has helped me to find strength I didn’t know I had.
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • http://healthygirlskitchen.blogspot.com Wendy (Healthy Girl’s Kitchen)

    Awesome thoughts.

    Just the other day a friend came up to me and asked me for advice on how to get in shape. I asked her what her current fitness program was and she said she was working out every day . . . every day . . . doing the Insanity videos in her basement. I said, “That’s amazing!” So what is it that you would like to improve upon? And she said, “Well, I’d like to lose ten pounds. ” and I was like (in my head) “If you lose ten pounds you might need to be hospitalized.” I told her flat out that she was suffering from Body Dysmorphia but she didn’t seem to care. It’s just like Emilie described. We are conditioned to hate our bodies when there is nothing wrong with them. We feel that we must vocalize this dissatisfaction or we won’t be accepted into the club.

    So afterwards, my husband, who was also present at the conversation, came up with a new condition: Body Euphoria. It is the state you are in after treating yourself well for a long time (which does include moderate exercise and nutritious, unprocessed food) and achieving your happy weight, where even if your body has no resemblance to a model in a magazine you are thrilled with how you feel.

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      Body Euphoria is great, I love that concept! It’s upsetting that we collectively have this idea that we have to do something in order to feel good about ourselves, that we’re good enough as we are. The idea of Body Euphoria combats that feeling–we don’t have to “earn” the right to love our bodies!
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • http://whatrunslori.com (what runs) Lori

    Funny (and slightly sad) how true the fact that women tend to go through body-bashing sessions with each other. It’s accepted that you shouldn’t love your body and it’s Ok to even talk to others about things you’d like different, like to change, or how badly you do see your own body- which can all correlate to how you see YOURSELF.

    Like you, like many of us, I have been through my little Hell and back with my body- my own self worth. I’m learning how much I really do love myself, my body, and my strength and determination. Maybe it takes age and years… Maybe it takes self-work. Whatever the reason, I would love to take your actions into my own life: Leave the negative self-talk (especially among others) behind. :)

    Great post!

    • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

      I think you’re right, it does take work (and age and maturity also help!) and definitely conscious effort but I think the more we take time to monitor what we’re saying and what we’re hearing other women say, the better things will get! It is the kind of work that is completely worthwhile.
      Emilie recently posted..Five-fingered runningMy Profile

  • Pingback: Body of Knowledge | I Came to Run

  • http://www.hblewett.com/blog Hanlie

    This is really an important post, Emilie, and I have enjoyed the comments too.

    I also refuse to participate in body bashing. Fortunately my best friend and I are totally on the same page about this!
    Hanlie recently posted..Roundup of the Week – 17-52 of 2011My Profile

  • http://www.icametorun.com/ Emilie

    Thanks, Hanlie! It’s great that you *and* your best friend refuse to body-bash. It’s so important to have friendships that are built on a healthy foundation.
    Emilie recently posted..Sunday run-down- April 25-May 1My Profile

  • Pingback: Feeling “Fat” « Recovery from Disordered Eating

  • Pingback: In an Effort to Build a Community Around Self-Love | Medicinal Marzipan

Previous post:

Next post: