Honoring Your Hunger Cues: Coffee, The Final Frontier

by Marzipan on January 28, 2011 · 29 comments

So this morning, as I was sitting in class painfully early, I was sort of idly bringing my 21 oz. coffee cup to my lips when I realized that my stomach was turning over, my heart was beating wildly out of my chest, and I was feeling a little repulsed by the idea of taking one more sip of coffee.  And in that second I was floored, because as someone who continues to work very hard on learning to eat intuitively, honor my hunger cues, and deconstruct my tendency towards emotional eating, here I was habitually pouring coffee down my throat – coffee that my body was actively rejecting and was having a negative impact on me.

It’s strange because all of the sudden I found myself encountering a whole new concept – the realm of the habitually consumed. This realm is home to the things that you ingest or do on a daily basis, and have become fused with your identity. As in, Hi I’m Marzipan and I’m not fully awake in the morning without at least three cups of coffee. This is an example wherein my understanding of myself is fused with my consumption of coffee.  Now, this identity does not take variation into account or days when I’ve had more or less sleep or when I’m sick or any of that – because in my heart I am a coffee drinker.

It seems that this happens whenever people feel passionately about their chosen routines – or if someone identifies with a group strongly. Likely, this happens with Healthy Living Bloggers, for whom healthy eating is a principle of group membership. This might interfere with their craving for something like an ice cream sundae or a cheeseburger or anything that is arguably not very healthy for you. It is interesting then how you understand the complication between what you do and what your body really wants.

If someone is a smoker, and they are accustomed to smoking a cigarette every couple of hours or so, it stands to reason that addiction aside, this action is habitual in nature. Are you stepping outside to smoke because you are having a nicotine craving or are you stepping out because it’s 3 PM and you ALWAYS smoke at 3 PM on your break from work? Are you drinking your afternoon cup of coffee because you are feeling especially tired and you need a pick-me-up, or are you imbibing out of sheer habit?

Even for people who have fought long and hard to reign in their emotional eating, bringing themselves back to the basics, and regaining trust in their body’s wants/needs – this gray zone of habitual consumption so frequently remains unaddressed. I would definitely think twice about mindlessly consuming an ice cream sundae if I wasn’t really hungry, but I would not think twice about refilling my to go mug and downing many ounces of a caffeinated beverage.  And it seems that is worth paying attention to.

Has this ever happened to you? Is there anything in your life that you mindlessly consume and seems exempt from efforts for moderation? Do you have any habits that you feel are 100% tied into your understanding of your self?

  • http://www.voiceinrecovery.com/blog/ Kendra (Voice in Recovery)

    Absolutely. I have moments like this where I realize, oh yah this xyz thing is actually NOT something I want, but think I should want because of habit or routine. This is why I try to break up my routine as much as possible. On weekends I don’t do coffee, I sleep in, take more breaks. I break the routines that have tired me out during the week. I have a ton of past habits I used to define as me, but now I do not define myself by my habits, but I am aware, and monitor habits to see if they are contributing to my life or not.
    Kendra (Voice in Recovery) recently posted..The “Enough” Tyrant &amp Other Self DoubtsMy Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Kendra I love that response – I’m also working on shaking up the routine on the weekends, and it’s so helpful to get out of a rut and reexamine habits. I’m going to try to shake it up a little more this week : )

  • http://ontherocksandstraightup.com Angie @ On the rocks and straight up

    I absolutely do this. Some mornings I leave half the coffee in the pot, and it’s only recently that I’ve realized that when I do this, I don’t necessarily miss it. I’ve started replacing it with tea throughout the day, because what my body wants is not necessarily a cup of coffee, but a hot cup of something just to warm up my hands.

    Sometimes I’ll go for a snack and realize that what I thought was hunger was thirst. It’s hard to listen to your body and hear “full.” It’s also hard to break habits, even if they’re good ones.
    Angie @ On the rocks and straight up recently posted..ExplodedMy Profile

  • http://imperfectlyhealthy.com Stacie @ Imperfectly Healthy

    I find myself doing this kind of thing more often now that I’m eating intuitively. I’ll be eating something that I’ve always thought I really liked (or even needed) and discovered that I don’t like it all or that it makes me feel crappy after eating it. It’s always such a revelation! If I wasn’t eating this way, I’m sure I would keep on eating/drinking it!

    And I’m the same as you – I can’t drink coffee without feeling a little nauseated getting a headache.
    Stacie @ Imperfectly Healthy recently posted..Why I Work OutMy Profile

  • http://www.abundantselfcare.com/ Christie {Abundant Self Care}

    This has happened to me with MANY foods/drinks. Coffee being one of them. I can remember, though, the first time drinking green tea made me want to hurl. I thought it was a fluke, so, again, the next day I made a cup of hot green tea (since I was trying to let go of coffee!!) and yet again, it make me want to hurl.

    Somehow, I had forgotten the hurl factor that green tea gives me and decided to have some a couple of weeks ago and once again, I was reminded that my body does not like green tea.

    It is very interesting what we uncover when we begin to actually listen to our bodies rather than our social selves or mind wanting relief from emotions and feelings.

    Fascinating stuff, indeed.
    Christie {Abundant Self Care} recently posted..Building Assertiveness in RelationshipsMy Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Ooooh I am so with you on the green tea. Every time I try to quit coffee I try so hard to like tea, but no matter how hard I try I just don’t. Something that has been useful however is both fresh juice with some ginger/lemon in it and green smoothies – both are energizing, but caffeine free. Love that.

  • http://ulteriorharmony.blogspot.com Ela

    This is a perfect analogy for self-identification as an ‘anorexic,’ or whatever. I just wrote about this in my blog a couple days ago. And it takes years to get comfortable performing behaviors that are not congruent with this identification.

    Kudos to you on recognizing it with the coffee. I wish my husband didn’t identify himself as ‘a coffee drinker.’…
    love
    Ela
    Ela recently posted..Static and Momentous Fears- Changes and a Raw Pea Soup RecipeMy Profile

  • http://www.110pounds.com Lisa

    I was that way with food. I was always eating. I’m still “always” eating but I eat healthy snacks and smaller meals.

  • max

    that was exactly how i stopped smoking cigarettes. just looked at it one day, and thought “what am i doing? this is gross.”
    but it is interesting to note that in the context of “intuitive eating” and listening to what your body needs/wants, coffee will totally throw you off balance. so it seems natural that when you actually look at what it is, you probably won’t want it. coffee is one of the most acidic foods you can put into your body, in terms of how your body processes foods. and your body is constantly trying to balance it’s alkaline/acid levels, so that makes it extremely hard to compensate with more alkalizing foods.
    anyways, keep up the good work! your blog is always interesting and inspiring to me!

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Oh Max – the cigarettes… They’re next. Thanks for sharing that info about the impact of coffee on your body’s natural digestion process. I think that I’m going to work on drinking less coffee and more water and juice. Xoxo

  • http://icametorun.wordpress.com Emilie

    When I was in ED recovery but still trying to hold onto it as hard as I possibly could, I found myself drinking coffee nonstop. Not only did it surpress my appetite, but it also became a habit that replaced the habit of eating. Its relationship to me sort of became circular–the coffee was a representation of my being thin and in control, while my feeling thin and in control became entirely tied to the coffee.

    Kind of surprisingly, I’m still able to drink coffee now that I’m much healthier. The difference is that now I drink it more slowly, and I drink it because I enjoy it. It’s part of my morning routine in a good way, because it actually helps me to slow down, and in slowing down, I drink a lot less.
    Emilie recently posted..A letter to CrawfordMy Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      This a PERFECT example of how this type of habit becomes fused with a sense of self, and unfortunately is the reason why so many people start consuming so much coffee. For me it was more about the control – when I was caffeinated I was invincible. I could move faster and accomplish more than in my wildest dreams.

  • http://applesandporsches.com Ellie Di

    What’s really infuriating (and frustrating) is to notice this kind of behaviour in yourself and feel helpless to do anything about it. The routine is so ingrained that you don’t know how to change it – saying, “Well, I just won’t do that anymore” doesn’t cut it. And then you start to spiral because the feeling of being helpless against a routine triggers other thoughts and behaviours. Gotta keep a tight rein on it somehow. Using concepts of intuitive eating can definitely help, I think. Practising mindfulness about what I’m doing during my day can only benefit me, in more areas than just my relationship with food.
    Ellie Di recently posted..Inspiration Station 018My Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Ellie I agree completely about utilizing mindfulness techniques – it can be so helpful just to pay attention to your actions and how they make your body feel. You might not be able to fix everything cold turkey, but switching things up every once and a while can feel so good.

  • http://zofasho.wordpress.com zoe (and the beatles)

    bah! i just gave up coffee for this very reason! my body seriously hates coffee…but i love it! it’s far too acidic for my poor, sensitive tummy to handle. plus, i found myself “addicted” to it within weeks. if i found myself tired, i drank coffee instead of just SLEEPING, which, obviously, my body was screaming at me to do. sometimes i drink decaf but i know i need to steer clear of coffee for a second (hard, as i work at starbucks…)

    oh, and hummus. let’s not even talk about how much hummus i can put away in a single day ;)
    zoe (and the beatles) recently posted..go climb a rock pleaseMy Profile

  • http://ascensionblog.wordpress.com Megan @ ascension blog

    Wow! What a thought-provoking post! Hm…I would have to say that, for me also, coffee consumption is more of a habit, rather than on an as-needed basis. My body is so accustomed to caffeine that I never experience the stimulating effect that coffee tends to provide for others (or, so they claim); I drink it because it’s comforting, I enjoy the taste, it passes time, it is often social, and yes, I identify as a ‘coffee-drinker’. Also, I live in Brazil, where coffee-drinking is habitual for EVERYONE.
    I think that calorie-counting and the use of artificial sweetener were/are habits that are really tied to my understanding of myself as a ‘restrictor’. I’m letting go of this self-identification now, and, thankfully, I’ve broken the calorie-counting habit; however, I still habitually avoid sugar and go for the artificial sweetener, even though I now know that it has a tendency to disrupt my digestion.
    Megan @ ascension blog recently posted..the Awesomeness 250111My Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Woah Megan, living in Brazil must be amazing!! How long have you been there? I Imagine that it’s a difficult habit to kick when everyone is drinking coffee all the time, and also when the coffee is so delicious! I hear you about the artificial sweetener. I go back and forth on the issue, and also have a hard time with sugar because it’s so bad for the enamel in your teeth… But then again artificial sweeteners are awful for your body. Ugh.

  • http://katywidrick.com Katy

    Last year, I found myself making a pouring a second cup of coffee in the morning — not because I wanted it, but because it was my routine. I thought it would be easy to cut back but it wasn’t … I had to wean myself off coffee completely, and only recently have felt OK bringing back a single cup a day. But I really enjoy that one cup!

    I also stopped biting my nails recently, and that made me realize that breaking routines takes a LOT of willpower.

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Katy, was it hard to wean yourself off initially? I’ve been pondering whether it would be more beneficial to cut it out completely or just reduce my consumption. The thought of an early morning without coffee sounds pretty painful, but my consumption since starting gradschool has gotten out of hand!

  • http://www.runeatrepeat.com Runeatrepeat

    Yeah, I’m similar to you on working on Intuitive Eating / Honoring body cues and have made some small realizations like this. Good job :)
    Runeatrepeat recently posted..Confession Thursday– Taco StuffersMy Profile

  • http://www.stronghealthyfit.wordpress.com Annie@stronghealthyfit

    I’m totally the same way with coffee. It’s become a habit, and even some days when I don’t need the caffeine I still feel like I need to drink coffee for some reason. I don’t realize in the moment that maybe I don’t have to have it every day.
    Annie@stronghealthyfit recently posted..Long Day- Short PostMy Profile

  • KCLAnderson (Karen)

    What an amazing post full of awareness!! My answers are yes, yes and yes!

    I’ve had the same experience with coffee (I still drink it but cut back to one cup except on Sundays). And sometimes I won’t drink a full cup if I am feeling my anxiety. Yogurt is a habit I got myself into but only after I found Greek-style yogurt. My naturopath wanted me to start eating it every day and I’d buy the regular kind and it just turned me off. Then someone recommended Greek and now I feel funny if I don’t eat it.

    On a related note, I used to wonder if certain cravings or “false” hunger was just due to habit (versus “emotional” eating) and now I think it was actually more due to certain physical imbalances in my body.

    Oh, and I really wanted to like green tea too but it just tastes like hot bitter water to me. I am not a tea fan in general but I do enjoy Good Earth’s Sweet & Spicy (which doesn’t have any sugar or sweetener in it) or camomile with lemon and agave (right before bed).
    KCLAnderson (Karen) recently posted..The Quality Of My TearsMy Profile

  • http://vivafat.com/ Chickie@Vivafat

    I’ve been battling my coffee addiction for years. I went through brutal headaches every time I went cold turkey, only to cave after a couple of months. Coffee soothes hunger, and there was a time when I took advantage of that, very unwisely so. I switched to black tea, and drank too much of it. Same with green tea–my stomach hated it when I drank more than two cups. And, oh, the one glass of (healthy, ha!) red wine every night–I got rid of that as soon as I found myself forming a mindless habit.

    As far as I’m aware, I’m free of compulsive eating/drinking habits now, but it wasn’t easy to get to that stage.

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com marzipan

      Thanks for your comment Chickie – I agree, it is very difficult to get to a stage where you are aware enough to recognize the habits that simply aren’t serving you well and are just residual from a time where you payed less attention. ::here’s hoping::

  • http://www.yumyucky.com Yum Yucky

    I don’t buy potato chips, but if you put them in front of me, the mindless consuming begins to activate immediately. So I just stay away from ‘em.
    Yum Yucky recently posted..Fitness Lessons From Some Stanky LaundryMy Profile

  • Rose

    I just came across your blog and I think it is brilliant! I want to thankyou for writing such an inspiring yet practical blog.

    I completely agree with this article, I uses to find myself all the time eating things because I want to be eating or I thought I needed something when in fact my body was crying out for something else. Unfortunately, it took a serious illness that I’ve been struggling with for 5 years now to wake me up to the fact that I need to listen to my body. Now, compared to everyone else, I am ultrasensative to the needs of my body, because if I’m not my body just crashes and I get really sick, but I still fall into traps every now and then.

    My worst one is energy drinks, particularly one called V which we have here in Australia (I’m not sure where else they have it.) I guess you could say it’s my coffee, since I can’t stand the taste of coffee. I cann’t drink it at all because it literally takes a day for me to become addicted. Energy drinks aren’t good for anyone, but for me they can make me really sick. But for some reason there is something in me that, even after all this time and knowing better, wants a quick fix to being tired so I can push through like superwoman, far beyond what my body can handle.

    So thankyou for the article. I think it is so true that most people eat/drink for emotional crutches that become habits far beyond the emotional need for it. I can’t wait to read more of your wonderful blog.

  • http://localcommunitymanagement.wordpress.com Liz

    I’m catching up on your excellent blog – please forgive me for my late comment…

    I’ve had this coffee-tied-into-my-identity experience as well: I used to work at Starbucks. I was even a Coffee Master, which meant I had special training in tasting coffee and in training others to taste coffee. In my younger years, this was a source of pride and professionalism for me, and I made life-long friends, with the same interests, in this position.

    In the beginning of my coffee days, I found myself in the doctor’s office. My stomach hurt in a weird new way; I was able to fall asleep but I hadn’t been sleeping through the night; I was jittery and pale. I didn’t even recognize where this was coming from. After hearing where I worked, my doc asked how much coffee I drank a day. I couldn’t answer the question. She suggested becoming more aware of what I was drinking by counting how many cups of coffee/shots of espresso I was having. I thought the appointment was a waste of money until the next day when the number quickly started adding up, when the tally reached 8 and I was still making myself another latte.

    I implemented two rules that week that let this part of my identity exist without the caffeine abuse. First and most importantly: no coffee to replace sleep. This means; no coffee if I’ve had less than 6 hours of sleep the night before, no coffee to stay awake at night, no coffee if the intent is to use it to tamper with my sleep cycle. Second, no bad tasting coffee. This is a harder one – in the first I’m conscious as I’m scheming. The second requires constantly being aware of the cup of coffee, which as noted above can be a challenge when its tied up in the whole experience.

  • http://movingforwardfromed.blogspot.com Heather

    I found this article really interesting because, since moving work at the start of the year, I have found myself reverting to old habits I had made some moderate headway in prior to this move. I’m eating in a way that I know is unhealthy for me. I’m eating to reassure myself. I’m eating to break up the day into manageable segments. I’m eating for comfort and friendship. I’m using sugar when I’m tired and overwhelmed. I KNOW I’m doing things to hurt myself – no one else – and yet in the moment I’m feeling comforted and not alone, and knowing it doesn’t make it easy to stop.
    Heather recently posted..Happy New YearMy Profile

  • Shohinigupta

    I cannot tell you how true this is in my case! I am a smoker and have been trying to find ways to quit but cannot. This post will surely make me think! Thanks for this!

Previous post:

Next post: