learning to eat healthfully without restriction

by Marzipan on July 10, 2010 · 10 comments

So, when I polled my readers recently for topics that they would like covered here, the lovely @djodrylapointe [follow her, she's lovely] asked me to address the topic of learning to eat healthfully, but without falling into restrictive dieting. And wouldn’t you know, this is one of my favorite topics these days? Because this can be difficult.

I often feel as though I’m negotiating with myself like I’m a small child. My inner malnourished bratbaby demands all kinds of food all day long – ice cream sundaes, bread products, cookies, crackers, assorted super fattening cheese laden delicousness.

Bratbaby demands food like this because this was the food she wasn’t allowed when she was a small fat child or a moderately fat teenager or during the many years of fruitless binge/diet/pain/punish/shame/binge cycle. She wants all of the foods that she was told she was too fat to enjoy. And now that I’ve unleashed her with my vow to eat intuitively, she is reeking havoc and stomping on things and demanding to be fed.

But really – can you blame her??

I can’t, and I rarely do. But I do try to reason with her on a tri-daily basis. I make bargains – ok, if you eat your vegetables now, you can have a cookie later. I work to eat healthfully, most of the time, but I do not get crazy about it and I definitely do not restrict myself. I learned a long time ago that restriction leads directly to binge, though sometimes not directly, but somehow, somewhere dietary disaster will strike, inevitably resulting in my consuming 75 x the amount of calories I would have consumed if I just let myself eat the effing cookie to begin with.

I have learned that, for me, restriction is an absolute danger zone.

Thus I strive to make healthy choices where I can, frequently, and to grow my appetite and palate for healthier foods. For example, recently I taught myself to love oatmeal for breakfast, thereby eliminating most of the eggs and cheese from my daily diet. I also at one point taught myself to love green smoothies because they allowed for me to get a major amount of my daily greens and iron consumption.

I strive to make healthy choices, so that if I need to eat french fries every day every once and a while, it is ok. We need to eliminate the fear of “bad” or “restricted” foods in order to reconnect with our natural hunger and cravings. Once the fear of previously off limits food is lifted, we can be free to enjoy eating according to our body’s natural rhythms.

What about you – do you have difficulty battling the close proximity of healthy eating and restriction? How do you cope with it? What makes it easier?

  • Lucy

    I really believe that you have to define “healthy” by not looking toward written guidelines or expert recommendations. I know what is healthy for my body, and it has helped me tremendously to cultivate a broader definition of healthy that takes into account having a peaceful relationship with my body and a relaxed, free-to-focus-on-the-important-things-not-foodfoodfood mind. And most of the time, that includes foods like fruit, veggies, whole grains, etc. But sometimes it means eating cereal for dinner or ice cream for breakfast. This has allowed me to eat healthfully (as I have defined it) and avoid restriction in the name of health.

  • http://www.diabetesdaily.com/baumgartel Rachel

    This post hit home with me.

    I have T2 diabetes and treat it with diet and exercise alone. Balanced meals with carbs in moderation because if I try to restrict carbs too much, it becomes an obsession, it becomes a source of high anxiety. And in turn, that anxiety defeats the purpose of eating low-carb because I end up with higher blood sugars due to the stress.

    Yet if I just stick to the balanced meals and carbs in moderation (and exercise), everything falls into place.

  • http://www.biggirlbombshell.com Jules – Big Girl Bombshell

    Healthy eating and restrictions…..I bargain a lot with myself lately too. One of the bargains is to say YES to trying new foods, tastes, etc at least once a week. Learning to say YES instead of NO is SO difficult to TRUST but I am working on it!
    Jules – Big Girl Bombshell recently posted..Wisdom Begins IN WonderMy Profile

  • http://www.clarityincreation.blogspot.com rebekah (clarity in creation.)

    i loved this post. so true.

    case in point: for years, i wouldn’t allow myself to have ice cream. i wasn’t fat, just far too chubby to be the kind of person who deserved ice cream, so i told myself.

    i lusted after it, and kinda secretly hated people who ate it. i would see skinny people and judge them for eating it, and see fat people and judge them for eating it! i was just generally unhappy with myself, ice cream, and others.

    when i finally decided to attack my disordered thoughts head on, i realized all this time i tortured myself, and… i don’t even like ice cream. it doesn’t do it for me. but all those years, i craveddd it so bad because i wouldn’t let myself eat it. what a waste!

    -rebekah
    rebekah (clarity in creation.) recently posted..SNACK ATTACK-My Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com admin

      I loved this comment rebekah, because this is how I feel about most of my life! What a waste! All that time stressing about NOTHING : ) Thanks so much. xo.

  • KCLAnderson (Karen)

    Have you read “Women Food & God” yet? It’s a must!!

    I’ve written down all the passages that resonate with me and will be sharing on my blog at some point, but here’s one I particularly like:

    “I didn’t want the cookies, I wanted the way being allowed to have them made me feel.”
    KCLAnderson (Karen) recently posted..What Does Strong Look LikeMy Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com admin

      gah! I haven’t!! but I super want to. it’s at the top of my list for when the summer mayhem calms down a little. thanks for sharing that passage though, it soooounds like an amazing book and I do really, really love Geneen Roth.

  • http://livingwithhealthyhunger.com Dorry

    Love this post! I laughed when I read about just letting yourself have the effing cookie b/c I totally relate…and because of that, I don’t deprive myself of foods that I’m craving. I have, however, learned healthier ways to prepare food or healthier alternatives for the foods I crave. So I’m not restricting but I’m getting some nutritional value from almost everything I eat. For me, it takes a lot devotion and planning. :)
    Dorry recently posted..Flashback Friday- “A Change Is Gonna Do You Good” editionMy Profile

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com admin

      Hey Dorry – that is totally the key!! I love it. Learning healthier ways to prepare food/healthier alternatives for the foods I’m craving. This is what I’m really into nowadays. For example – craving: ice cream sundae, solution: MUMBO DUMBO [soy milk, chocolate sauce, peanut butter, frozen bananas blended into a smoothie]. It’s so satisfying to find healthier foods that I love to eat. Thanks for stopping by.

  • Pingback: 50 Best Blogs for Beating Food Addiction

Previous post:

Next post: