On being “gay”, looking straight, and a new generation of queer

by Marzipan on August 13, 2009 · 7 comments

Lately this has been happening to me with stunning regularity: an older gay person around town looks at me, kind of cocks her head to the side, and says (please note condescension), “Thats so sweet that you are in love, is this your first serious relationship with a girl?” Or something of the like.

And maybe its August, and maybe I have six jobs, and maybe that person is just JUMPING on my last nerve, but something about this scenario makes me want to claw my eyes out. 

Flashback to four or so years ago when I was studying in Amsterdam, when my host mother looks across the dinner table at me and says, “Well I just don’t understand how you get any girlfriends, looking the way you do. You know, we have a saying about people like you here, which roughly translates to eating on both sides of the fence.”  To which I responded, “Um. Well. This is just how I look…” 

photo/cupcakes by the amazing hello naomi, click for flicker page

photo/cupcakes by the amazing hello naomi

So as a recap: I am queer. I started dating girls when I was fourteen. I have had seven relationships with girls to date, ranging from two months to a year in length, and I have casually dated quite a few more. I have dated ONE boy in my life – well two, if you count the one in high school, but that really was quite minimal. This is not to say I have only slept with one boy, but again, minimally. 

However, I am relatively attractive. I have long(ish) curly hair. I wear mascara. I love few things more than the perfect summer dress. I wear feminine jewelry on a consistent basis. I have (unfortunately) huge boobs. I am girly. 

So, fast forward to my current happenings, to the point where I off handedly respond, “Actually, I’ve been dating girls since I was fourteen.” And watch the jaw opposing me hit the floor. I mean REPEATEDLY. I have never denied the fact that perhaps I do not fit the stereotypical “lesbian” mold. I also am not all together surprised that this is continuously happening – but I do find it interesting.

As a part of a new queer generation, I grew up in a conspicuously gay place, amidst many gay people, with homosexuality being the predominant norm in the relationships that I was directly impacted by. I was taught, unfailingly, that sometimes (often) you fall in love with the person and not the gender. I was shown, again and again, that people had fluid sexuality and what was true one day, was not necessarily going to be true the next. 

This is not to say that I didn’t have a WICKED hard time coming out, because despite all of the gay bliss that was surrounding me, I was very surprised when I developed feelings for my first girlfriend. But it is to say that I have not encountered very many obstacles in the way of my sexuality, and tend to live in a happy little bubble where my reality is that everyone is loved and accepted just the way they are. 

But then, things like this happen to me, and I have to find it almost laughable. BECAUSE OF MY HAIR? Seriously, you think I’m not gay, because of my HAIR. Is it 2009? 

Anyway, not that I think any of you need it, but apparently I am living in a time warp over here: not all queer people look the same.  I like my hair. I like wearing dresses. I like my girlfriend. And I find all of these elements perfectly suited for one another.

  • http://sexgenderbody.com sexgenderbody

    Awesome read. Thanks for letting me know about it via twitter. Please consider cross-posting this at http://sexgenderbody.com . Lots of folks that read our site would love this post.

    -arvan

  • http://allwordofmouth.wordpress.com Clint

    I’ve dated men and women throughout my life, and I have had wonderful relationships with both. I’m hesitant, however, to label myself in any way, much to the horror of many of the gay men around me.

    At the moment I’m with men; however, people are always surprised that I am. I’m sorry I don’t fulfill your expectations for queerness, people.

    • http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com admin

      Haha, awww Clint. Well I obviously don’t either.
      And somehow I think that both of us are going to be perfectly fine.
      Thank You.

  • http://www.steffsays.com steff (steffsays)

    i’m so glad you linked back to this old post so i got a chance to read it. i just want to shout a great big AMEN at you! i totally understand this dilemma…and then some!

    in addition to being very feminine looking, i am in a long-term serious relationship with a man. however i have dated & loved both men and women since i was 17 and have self-identified as queer since that time. being active in the LGBT community is HUGELY important to me and when i was dating women i felt generally accepted despite by femme appearance. but these past 5 years i have had to explain myself SO many times to other LGBT folks who seem to see me as “less” queer than they are…like i’m some sort of traitor because i happened to find “the one” and he happens to have a penis. god forbid my partner actually wants to come some sort of queer event with me to show his support…i get dirty looks like you wouldn’t believe!

    ARGH! i’m so sick of having to validate myself and my identity to people who just can’t wrap their heads around the fact that *i* don’t change based on my partner’s gender. here’s some hope for the future though: i do a lot of work with LGBT teenagers, and NONE of them give me any shit when i explain that i am a queer female in a relationship with a man. some ask questions, and that’s fine…but they all “get it” and except it. hallelujah!

    phew. had to get that out there. :)
    steff (steffsays) recently posted..Eeek! The D Word!!My Profile

  • http://s.rvxn.org sui
  • http://Wearingmascara.com Julie @ Wearing Mascara

    This is such a great post. Thank you for linking to it!!

  • Pingback: Clickity Click! | The Karina Chronicles

Previous post:

Next post: